That was a tough title to write. I love Craig Biggio. I do. He was everything you could ask for in a ballplayer. But he was not as great as the man who enters the Baseball Hall of Fame Sunday, Jeff Bagwell.
Stats
Look at the Astro single season records held by Bagwell:
- Highest BA – .368 (1994)
- Highest OBP – .454 (1999)
- Highest SLG – .750 (1994)
- Highest OPS – 1.201 (1994)
- Most Runs scored – 152
- Most Home runs – 47 in a season (1994)/13 in a month (June 1994) – Including most in one season at Minute Maid – 28 (2000) in the Astrodome 23 (1994) and on the road – 30 (1999)
Career-wise?
- His 449 HRs are 123 (38% more) than second place Lance Berkman
- His 1529 RBIs are 354 (30% more) than second place Biggio
- Most walks with 1401
- He trails Biggio in hits, 2Bs, runs, because injuries cut short his career and he played in 700+ less games and had 3100+ less ABs than his buddy
- His career .297 BA is behind Altuve and his .408 OBP, .540 SLG and .948 OPS are a tad behind Lance Berkman. Of course his numbers were over a much longer time and included his late decline
Intangibles and others
- Rookie of the year – 1991
- MVP -1994
- Was an All-Star 4 times, though he failed to make the All-Star team in two seasons when he was top 10 MVP and one year when he finished with 124 runs, 34 HRs and 111 RBIs
- Just by the eyeball test, even though he was not the swiftest Astro by a long shot he was one of the best base runners in the game, rarely making a mistake on the bases, taking extra bases often and he stole more than 30 bases as a 1B twice in his career.
- Again by eyeball he was one of the best right handed fielding 1Bs in the game due to his roots as a 3B and he perfected the art of charging the bunt and gunning the lead runners down.
Great Core Years
They often talk about how true Hall of Famers have a big core of years when they were truly great.
If you look at Jeff Bagwell’s core 10 seasons from 1994-2003, here are his numbers.
He averaged 116 runs scored, 36 doubles, 37 HRs, and 115 RBIs. Remember that 9 of his 15 seasons were in the cavernous Astrodome. He also would have had even higher numbers, if he had not lost about 100 games in 1994 and 1995 to two HBPs to his hands.
During those 10 seasons he averaged .301 BA/,419 OBP/.574 SLG/.993 OPS. One season like that would have been what most players would love to have on their resume.
Conclusion
Bags was the greatest Astro to play for the team. He did not have the longevity of the man he will always be linked to Craig Biggio. He did not have the playoff success of the only other man who was a great hitter and power hitter for the team. Lance Berkman. And he may one day get displaced by a Jose Altuve or Carlos Correa for greatest Astro ever.
But as he enters the Hall of Fame Jeff Bagwell can proudly wear the cap of the Astros as the greatest player to ever wear that cap to date.


131 responses to “The greatest Astro enters the Hall of Fame”
I agree with you. My son grew up loving the Astros, and Bagwell was his guy. When I grew up loving the Astros, we never kept a player long enough to be able to compare with Bags.
LikeLiked by 1 person
The only thing holding Bagwell out of the HOF was the Astrodome and today he over came that.
LikeLike
Will Harris could not pitch yesterday and was placed back on the DL last night. Reymin Guduan has been recalled.
LikeLike
Ouch – well that explains why he wasn’t brought in late.
Note – the Astros were mentioned as kicking the tires on Cards Lynn – would they ask for their draft picks back?
LikeLike
I always thought it was unfair that Frank Thomas (who shares a birthday and a 1991 ROY trophy with Bagwell) went straight in while Bags waited.
I know Thomas was looked at as “naturally” a big man – Bags grew bigger along the way. I know that Thomas though very close in BA/OBP/OPS hit more dingers and had more RBIs. But Thomas had the luxury of playing about 60% of his games as a DH. He was never the fielder nor the baserunner that Bagwell was.
Well it does not matter today as they are both among the baseball immortals.
LikeLiked by 2 people
Dan, only issue I have is you say, “He was not as great as the man.”
LikeLike
As a ballplayer
LikeLike
My apologies for this comment. No thought, or wrong thought, behind it.
LikeLike
No problem – I see where you are coming from on it
LikeLike
Here we go again…..McCullers walked the first two hitters. What in the HE!! Is wrong G with this kid!???
LikeLike
congratulations Baggy! you truly were the best astro ever.
LikeLiked by 2 people
So if Harris is out an extended period do they try to use Peacock in that role? Is he able to go multiple games in a row?
LikeLike
Bagwell at the podium on MLB network
LikeLike
I am impressed! At least, he had his shirt tail tucked in, a tie on, and a jacket.
LikeLiked by 2 people
Bad day at black rock so far for the Astros.
LikeLike
I find it interesting that Robert Ford, says McCann has to go to the mound to settle McCullers down when things start to go a wry. Indeed McCullers problems are between his ears. I’m wondering if Hinch pulls him out of the rotation, and let’s him pitch out of the pen for awhile. Think he would go ballistic if Hinch does that???
Musgrove isn’t much better today…..looks like it isn’t our day today.
LikeLike
He has the stuff (his arm not between the ears). Seems to too easily let his personality throw his mechanics off.
LikeLike
Guess we give this game up. Sip on the mound.
LikeLike
Tony only gave up 5 runs while getting 1 out – not too shabby huh?
LikeLike
*GRANDSLAM* Tony Sipp should collect the rest of him money, and be shown the door. We have ALL had enough.
LikeLiked by 1 person
I fully agree.
LikeLike
OK. Someone reassure me we don’t need any more pitching.
LikeLiked by 2 people
The leak, in the bullpen, turned into a river today!
LikeLike
Not me.
LikeLike
Got to hear Bagwell at the induction (790 am)…….and I cried like a baby. I sat and thought of ALL those games in the Dome, and how exciting it was to see those guys play!! For all of his personal demons he will remain one of my favorite players❤
LikeLiked by 2 people
I’m not trying to be hateful, or angry I’m totally serious. Something has gone south with McCullers, and I’m worried about the kiddo. Losing grates on your nerves something fierce……and most guys can work through it, but as high strung as Lance is, I’m not sure putting him out every 5th day is a good idea. It seems to most of us, it’s not his “stuff” but more mental. Could he be having trouble at home? It’s something gang, and I don’t see it getting better anytime soon. I remember when Gregersen had to leave for a few days last year, in fact he did that twice. I’m worried about McCullars….I really am.
Keuchel is gonna be fine, it might take another start or two to get back in the game for him, but I’m not worried.
When you have 2 out of your 3 core players on the DL……it leaves a glaring hole. Boy have these guys missed Springer and Correa!!
Sandy…..you are absolutely correct WE. NEED. ANOTHER. STARTING. PITCHER.
LikeLike
We really do. If nothing else, it will take some of the pressure off McCullers and Keuchel. They need to do some housecleaning in the bullpen as well. Sipp has to go. Period.
LikeLike
Mrs. Sarge stated that, during the telecast of the game today, Steve Sparks was piped into the television portion and he was asked about McCullers. Sparks stated that McCullers has lowered his arm as he pitches. So, I ask, why does Strom not see this in videos and make the corrections?
LikeLike
I heard that too and for awhile it looked as if he was better at finding the plates but was getting hit hard, Inevitability finally set in. I’m not sure what is happening but the situation concerns me. 1 for 6 with RISP and 9 LOB with 6 of those coming in the 1st 3 innings. We definitely need Correa and Springer back. Yes I know Correa is out for 6 – 8 weeks but still. Now Harrris on the DL. I believe that we’re going to need BP help. We may be starting to see some tired arms out there. If nothing else we need to be “Sippless”.
LikeLiked by 1 person
So, what do the Rangers get in trade for a guy they gave up Lewis Brinson and a good pitching prospect for last year? Lucroy to the Rockies for a PTBNL.
LikeLike
If “sources” are accurate, Lance Lynn is on his way to Houston. Being a rental, it should not hurt nearly as much as Gray would.
LikeLike
Where did you see THAT???? Why on God’s green earth would they sign him??
Heck Peacock is better than Lance Lynn PLUS he’s just coming off Tommy John surg. Lord….I hope you’re wrong. Really I do.
LikeLiked by 1 person
Becky – Lynn is a darned good pitcher. Yes, his 3.20 ERA is a bit higher than Peacock’s current ERA but it is in alignment with his career ERA of 3.34, which really is a very good number. Peacock has only this one year of good numbers in comparison.
My bigger complaint is he has been pretty up and down in the playoffs and that should be the focus.
I don’t know what the front office is thinking right now – would they go after Verlander and his huge salary even if the Tigers don’t want to pay it down much? Would they go after Lynn on a rental? Is Sonny G still on their radar? (Lynn is a bit better than Gray this season, but would be one and done.)
And the bullpen is leaking like a sieve – what are their plans for that?
LikeLike
Justin Wilson to the Cubs. That leaves Britton, and Hand for lefty relievers.
LikeLike
And Sipp.
LikeLike
Not a huge return for Wilson. I wonder if HOU was involved and Avila would only discuss off limit guys.
LikeLike
Lee May, the big piece that came to the Astros in the Joe Morgan trade died at 74.
LikeLike
Well as I have stataed100 times in last month make the trades, otherwise I fear a short playoff run. The playoffs Pitching , Pitching, and Pitching.
LikeLiked by 1 person
Question what would hurt more loosing some good young prospects or not getting past The LDS? We will still have our core for 2018.
LikeLike
I was wondering the same thing. I thought one of the reasons for all those terrible years was to stock prospects to help acquire top tier players.
There’s going to be a lot of disappointed fans if they don’t go deep into the playoffs.
LikeLike
Bagwell’s 1994 season is the most incredible I’ve ever witnessed. Every time I turned on the radio or TV, Bagwell was on base, or rounding the bases , or clearing the bases. A thing of beauty is what it was. The numbers he would have put up had it been a full season and he had not been injured just boggles the mind.
LikeLiked by 1 person
It is one of those maddening things roadthriller. If…..you extend his 110 games worth of production in 1994 to 162 games it would have looked like this
153 runs scored, 47 doubles, 57 HRs, 171 RBIs, 442 total bases……maybe those PED concerns have some basis??
LikeLike
It’s beginning to look like we do need some help. Lynn might not be a bad addition if the price isn’t too high given he’s a free agent next year. We definitely need a LH reliever, no if’s, and’s or buts about it. This all about getting us through the ALDS playoffs because right now we appear to be somewhat suspect.
LikeLike
Don’t give up right now. The future counts,
LikeLike
Smart ownership and a GM can Balance both World Championships and the future .
We need to become the New England Patriots of baseball. Make the deal Uncle Jeff…
LikeLiked by 1 person
I would like to point out that the Patriots rarely trade for players at the trade deadline – they tend to trade players who will be free agents for draft picks like they did with their starting LB Jamie Collins last season.
LikeLike
Its was meant to be more about their success of long term winning, balancing the art of that., not a specific comparison to the differences of player transactions of MLB and the NFL,
LikeLike
I understand – the key you are saying is that they maximize the present and the future. It helps to have the greatest QB in charge.
LikeLike
Well here is one deal
https://www.mlbtraderumors.com/2017/07/blue-jays-trade-francisco-liriano-astros.html
LikeLike
Looks like they want Liriano to be that lefty reliever
LikeLike
Interesting. ..I wonder who we gave up?
LikeLike
They are talking like an OF is going back – I’m thinking the other Tucker (preston) or maybe Teoscar Hernandez
LikeLike
Mlbtraderumors says it is Nori Aoki….
LikeLike
Aoki and “a minor league player”
LikeLike
Works for me.
LikeLike
Liriano is okay as long as he does not have to pitch to righties.
LikeLike
Good lefty in the pen Like it
LikeLike
Works for me if they ship Ship somewhere far away.
LikeLike
Ship Sipp.
LikeLiked by 1 person
So….does sending Aoki to the Jay’s, mean Fisher stays up with the Astros? Boy, I sure hope so!!! Can’t wait to see what else Luhnow has up his sleeve!!!
LikeLiked by 1 person
yes
LikeLike
And Jumbo Diaz? Another secret weapon?
LikeLike
So far, so good.
LikeLike
When a guy is listed at 315, you’ve got to figure he goes 350.
LikeLike
Hey, lay off the fat jokes. Those get to be very personal.
But you are about 100 pounds over my weight class with this one.
LikeLiked by 1 person
And the prospect going to the Blue Jays is Teoscar Hernandez who has been passed up by Fisher and Tucker in the pecking order
LikeLike
So we got a LOOGY for both Aoki and Hernandez?
LikeLike
the Yankees get Sonny Gray UGH They just became a lot better
LikeLike
If the Yankees really got Sonny Gray for the three prospects mentioned, seems we could have offered a sweeter deal and still not done much damage to our minor league depth.
LikeLike
Bizarre. Gray could have been dealt this winter and still brought a sizable return.
LikeLike
Dodgers just Got Darvish Dang man , the best record in baseball got Darvish. UGH
LikeLike
Darvish apparently traded to Dodgers. Looks like we won’t face him again until October!
LikeLike
If we make it to late October.
LikeLike
If this trading day was supposed to impress us…….I can tell you RIGHT NOW Jeff Luhnow failed this team, and these fans. It’s telling me that Brad Peacock now has a permanent spot in the rotation……and I’m glad. With the way McCullers has been pitching, I would NOT be surprised to see him go on the DL again, so the kid can get his mind straight. I’m pi$$ed.
LikeLike
I think you summed it pretty good there Becky we get a D, LMJ now on the DL reed and reed coming up , DK could be next back on the DL
Not getting a warm and fuzzy some playoff teams got way better and we are suddenly leading the league in the DL
LikeLike
I wonder if it is possible to pick up a Verlander in an after the trade deadline trade….oh probably not.
LikeLike
I wanna hear Jeff Luhnow tell us *W H Y* he didn’t trade for Sonny.
GRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRR
LikeLike
Dan, technically yes I think. But doesn’t he have to clear waivers?
LikeLike
Yes but if someone claimed him they would be responsible for his whole salary and of course if he was claimed the Tigers could pull him back
LikeLike
TOLD YOU!!! They put McCullers on the DL, and called up Reed.
LikeLike
Becky you are some kind of psychic swami.
Can you predict something nicer like the Astros winning the whole enchilada?
LikeLike
I think they called up Feliz
LikeLike
Him too…both him and Reed
LikeLike
Have to admit, I was looking for a big deal, but Jumbo was not what I had in mind. Sorry 45.
LikeLike
Jumbo Jets are large, not fat. So you are OK on that one.
LikeLiked by 1 person
It is possible that Oakland did not want to keep Sonny in the division.
LikeLike
That is probably it
LikeLike
I have to believe the Yankees made the best offer.
LikeLike
Our lineup looks weak compared to last month. Bertrand in LF again. What’s up with that.
LikeLike
Beltran. Dang phone.
LikeLike
I wrote four starts ago that Lance McCullers told Brian McCann, “my back” after he retired the side and grimacing 1st inning…
LikeLike
I guess we’ll find out the story eventually. At this point I’m disappointed but not downtrodden. Lets see what happens in the next series or two. I want to get our hitting back on track for sure.
LikeLike
Keuchel was not happy last year’s trading deadline, and he made his feelings pretty clear. Look for him to voice his displeasure again……and I DON’T BLAME HIM IF HE DOES. I’m done ranting on about this, good luck to the AL team that faces the Dogers in the Word Series, because it doesn’t look like it will be the Astros.😠
LikeLiked by 1 person
Our pitching has been giving up a lot of runs – and I fully expect that to continue. We are going to need a whole lot more offensive punch from Reddick, Gurriel, Beltran and Gat-Can if we are going to play .500 ball the rest of the way.
LikeLike
We should get Springer back at the end of the week – that will help unless he flounders for a bit
I don’t see Reddick doing more than he has done
Beltran looks incapable of turning it on anymore
We should get more out of Fisher than we have been getting from Aoki
Gurriel has been slumping – needs to turn it around
Need Bregman to get on a bigger roll – he has been hitting better lately – needs to do it in more of a clutch way
What happens when Altuve comes back down to this planet?
LikeLike
OK – we have two guys coming off the 25 man (Aoki and McCullers) and two guys coming on the 25 man (Reed and Feliz) ….who comes off for Liriano or did I miss something?
LikeLike
I saw a note that Liriano would report Tuesday. On Astros web site 25 man is set as you noted. 13 pitchers, 2 catchers, DH, 6 IF, and 3 OF.
LikeLike
Also, Liriano pitched 6 innings on Saturday. He could not pitch with 4 days rest until after Tuesday.
LikeLike
So does Feliz go back down or Sipp out the door?
LikeLike
Probably the former, would prefer the latter. Actually, I’d prefer Feliz stays down and Sipp goes away and we get somebody else, but hey…
LikeLiked by 1 person