Happy Halloween, Astros fans. Jim Crane left something on our porch Friday night, and we’re all trying to figure out whether it’s candy or a rock.
The Astros hired Randy Flores as the 15th general manager in franchise history. Flores is 51, has spent more than a decade in the Cardinals’ front office, and has run their drafts for the last 10 years as scouting director and then assistant GM.
He also pitched eight seasons in the big leagues as a lefty reliever and won a World Series ring with St. Louis in 2006.
There’s even a Halloween twist. The Cardinals hired Flores as scouting director in 2015 to replace Chris Correa, the executive who went to prison for hacking into the Astros’ database. You can’t make this stuff up, can you?
Until Thursday, everybody thought this job belonged to Matt Kleine, the Brewers’ assistant GM. He walked the red carpet with Crane at the Houston Sports Hall of Fame event earlier this month.
The Athletic’s Chandler Rome reported that Houston offered Kleine the job Wednesday evening, hours before Milwaukee won the World Series. By Friday night, Flores had it instead. It appears that Kleine never pulled his name out, but sources told Rome he may have wanted more money or the title of president of baseball operations.
So who turned down whom? Did Kleine walk away from Houston, or did Crane refuse to give the man who just helped build a World Series champion the authority he asked for?
What kind of authority will Flores really have?
After Dana Brown was fired in August, Crane, Jeff Bagwell and three assistant GMs ran baseball operations by committee. Crane is about as hands-on as an owner gets, and it seems that Bagwell is still heavily involved in baseball decisions.
If Kleine asked for the president’s title and Crane said no, that may tell us how Crane feels about anybody else running the show. Or it could just possibly be that Kleine asked for way too much and lost the bet.
Flores has never run a front office. His first job is hiring a manager to replace Joe Espada. After that, he inherits a team that went 81-81, got swept by the White Sox, and had one of the worst minor league systems, according to various surveys.
Will Flores pick the next manager, or will Crane and Bagwell pick one and let Flores announce it? Is he going to rule the roost, or is he a puppet with a nice title?
And I am curious: Why was Crane seemingly so hurried in making the choice? Was it that he’d just done his homework, had his top 2-3 and pulled the trigger? Or did he feel he needed someone in place by December 1, when the lockout will apparently start?
I’ll give Flores this much. His drafts seem to have found some pretty good players after the first round, and a team with Houston’s farm system needs a man who can find players like Roy Oswalt (20th), J.D. Martinez (20th) and Dallas Keuchel (7th).
Flores and Crane meet the media Monday at 10 a.m. at Daikin Park. Watch carefully who fields the questions about the manager search, and that may tell you a lot about who’s really in charge.
So what did Crane leave on our porch, a trick or a treat?


25 responses to “Trick or Treat? Astros Get a New GM”
One more question: How long will it be before Kleine is hired as the new President of Baseball Operations for another organization? Milwaukee is primed for poaching now after its WS win, and Kleine is certainly more of a known entity after dating the Astros.
LikeLike
Thanks for this quick post, Chip.
LikeLike
We know Flores was not the first choice of the Astros.
We sort of know the Astros would not give Kleine the “Director of Baseball Operations” title.
Kleine or Flores? I don’t think it makes much of a difference because for Crane and Bagwell it will be business as usual. I just don’t see our owner remaking his or Bagwell’s way of doing business.
The Cardinals, a storied franchise, are no big deal these days. They’ve been to the post-season just four times in the past 11 years. They’ve won the division twice. Lost in the Wild Card round three times. Made the NLCS once, lost that series 4-0.
So although Flores was only an AGM, he’s obviously worked with a group that has not gotten big things done in St Louis. Maybe he was stifled.
It’s hard to critique a signing. And it’s going to take years to figure out whether Randy Flores is the right guy for the Houston job.
I guess we’ll get hints of how well Flores is able to operate within the Crane-Bagwell system. Can our GM make a difference? Can any Astro GM make a difference?
LikeLike
The Astros made their first new acquisition of the Randy Flores era, or maybe by our existing committee of AGM’s/Bagwell yesterday.
27 year old Evan Reifert of the Rays AAA affiliate strikes minor league guys out and walks a lot of them too. It was a cash deal.
LikeLike
Gold Glove for Walker!
Christian Walker becomes Astros’ first Gold Glove first baseman since 2021
LikeLike
Congrats to Walker. He does make the plays at first. However I don’t think there are clubs willing to pick up half his salary in a deal that would bring us a legitimate prospect or two though. That might be helpful. And maybe the Astros will try to move him, but Christian is really not one of our biggest problems right now.
Pena should be the first big move. And unless we get a shortstop in return, or as part of some other upcoming deal, moving Walker would leave us with a hole. I don’t think putting Correa back to short is a solution. I do think Paredes and Correa can be helpful at the two corner infield positions. Of course, maybe our new GM already has things figured out and our brain trust is ready to give him carte blanche.
LikeLike
It will be fascinating to see what moves if any will happen with the lockout/strike looming.
The team needs to make moves for the future but it takes two to tango and can a person who has never had that responsibility find trade partners and good trade returns in this atmosphere.
LikeLike
A note from our good friend oldpro
“Dan: I got my e-mail problems straightened out, which allows me to contact you. Still can’t manage to get back on Chipalatta. Walker got a GG tonight and that makes him more attractive in a trade. A rebuilding team doesn’t need him. When Yordan wins his MVP, his value will max out and he needs to be traded. A rebuild does not have room for a $30 million a year DH and Altuve’s salary, too. Let Altuve DH until he retires. Trade Hunter Brown for some good prospects. Move Isaac to 1B for his last year.
We had a .500 record with these guys, including the MVP and we went nowhere. Let’s get our draft picks down into the 8-12 range and get some good draftees and some stud prospects in the trades and hope that there is some kind of cap in the future to control payrolls and keep us protected.
We (Mom and I) are getting healthier, but older, also. Please tell everyone I miss them, check in every day and always add a star to the blog and hope to find a way back to the blog. All of you are doing a wonderful job. Glad we have a new GM. Let’s rebuild and become a force again.
LikeLiked by 1 person
Great to hear from you 1oldpro. I agree with your Astro assessment. We typically do.
Please stay well. And I hope you solve the access problem.
Best,
Daveb
LikeLike
I still have to wonder if the Dec 1 lockout date is cause for Crane to have someone in place quickly. He apparently pivoted fast from Kleine to Flores.
My questions: Can Flores make substantial moves over the next 28 days? Will teams consider him on a honeymoon and be interested to deal?
Could you consider it an advantage if you make deals now when there is certainty? Rather than wait until after the lockout ends and deals are in place with MLBPA and you not know what free agency, salary caps, luxury taxes will look like?
I’ll be watching the next few weeks a little more closely than normal.
LikeLike
But Chip don’t you think there is no certainty now? They have no idea what whether there will be a work stoppage, how long that will run and what the eventual CBA will be. I guess you could blindly go forward for the next 28 days ignoring what is coming, but you have to think that everyone will be hesitant to make any significant deals at this point. Maybe I’m wrong – we are heading into a very grey area.
LikeLike
I would think part of it is that the new Manager would want to get to know his roster a bit before he won’t even be allowed to talk to them.
And as far as deal making goes, from what I’ve been reading, there was a flurry of activity leading up to the last lock out in 21-22.
LikeLike
Dan, just a hunch. Wondering if he’s not planning/wanting to get ahead of the curve. Does he know what’s coming in the lockout? Does he not want to get left out in the curve? If he’s wanting to make a big splash (say, Pena, etc.), there will be teams who will be ‘in’.
As for ‘certainty’, it will be another year before there is certainty. Even after a deal is struck, there will be months to try to figure out what’s in the deal, what it means and how it affects you.
And, you don’t have to have ‘everyone’ involved to make a deal for a player like Pena, or, even Paredes, if that’s where it’s headed. Walker, yes. Correa, yes.
Again, just wondering out loud, really. He wanted to get a guy in place sooner than later, so it says to me anyway that he’s thinking it would be smart to have a GM before things get crazy… we will see…
LikeLike
Randy Flores’ dad is a pastor emeritus at a church in Houston. Interesting.
LikeLike
I just watched the replay of the press conference. It’s clear this club will not be broken up and everyone traded. Jim Crane reiterated his business model. No surprise. Dan, don’t worry, Yordan will not be traded away. That means a bunch of Jose Altuve at second base.
I have to hope the consensus in-house is to move Pena. That was not discussed either. Not one tough question from anyone. Moving Pena might help with pitching and maybe even get us an outfielder. But I’m guessing any acquisitions will lean more towards guys that can help the ML roster now in small ways and less on prospects. No headline deals. So at this point, my guess would be Pena is with the club at least until the deadline in 2027.
No Bagwell around. No questions asked about why the Kleine deal did not work out. I suspect those queries were specifically forbidden.
LikeLike
“I suspect those queries were specifically forbidden.” What is this a North Korean dictator presser? We used to have true journalists and now I have to wonder how many toe the line in these pressers so they don’t get cut out when news is released later. I am upset that some basic questions get skipped – we should not have better questions than the people allowed in that room and they should not be afraid to answer something about whatever the heck they are doing.
LikeLike
And really, shouldn’t Bagwell be around?
LikeLike
Jake Meyers outrighted and others added to the 40 man.
Hours after being introduced as new Astros GM, Randy Flores is already making changes | khou.com
LikeLike
It was nice knowing Jake. Great defense, no arm, did not hit enough, had trouble staying healthy. But he was very well liked. Getting released now will give him a better shot at getting on a 40 man roster before everything shuts down.
LikeLike
I’m finding it really hard to offer any worthwhile comments here. I’m choosing to be optimistic on the Flores hire because you may recall a few months back I posted about the Cardinals offense. Looking at their WAR, 5 of the top 9 were drafted by STL. The other 4 were international free agent signings. After that, number 10 came from the Red Sox system, but 11 and 13 were both drafted by STL. In regards the the Astros, using that same criteria, Pena, Correa, and Spence are the only hitters in our top 10 WAR for 2026 who were drafted or signed by the organization as an amateur.
I wanted to write a long analysis of free agents we could chase, but what’s the point? We can’t bring Kevin Gausman to town unless he’s the only FA we sign and are willing to pay him top of the rotation money to be a 4th starter. I’m resigning myself to a tough year or two if we don’t have it ruined by a lockout.
LikeLike
Devin, I understand. The Flores hire is a roll of the dice. He, obviously, wasn’t the first choice. Was he even the second? We don’t know.
But I still maintain that Crane felt he had to make a move to set up the lockout.
The experts believe we’re headed for a repeat of 2021 when there was a flurry of activity in November. Teams committed $1.9 billion to free agents in the month leading up to the end of the previous CBA.
If that’s the case, the clock is ticking and Flores won’t have a honeymoon. No mulligans or do-overs. It’s the deep end on Day 1.
Free agents may not be at the top of the Astros’ list (at least the big ones) but there are a couple of players (Pena and Brown) who could bring a haul and create a huge reset for Houston. I’m torn if they need to do a complete rebuild or just use the existing elite players to retool. Look at what Tucker brought. Do you think Pena and/or Brown could bring more?
How many of that ‘haul’ could be playing in Houston next season alongside Paredes, Wesneski, and Cam?
NOTE: This is not a prediction. It’s more of an observation that we are likely to see activity in the next 28 days.
LikeLike
Many people thought Tucker was still ascending when the Astros traded him shortly before his 28th birthday. The Cubs fans believed they were picking him up with a legitimate chance to sign him long term. Pena is 29 already and similarly has just the one year of team control remaining. Brown is 28 and has two years remaining. Before Tucker got hurt in 2024 he was having an MVP caliber season. Brown has shown flashes of being a Cy Young contender. I think Pena has reached his peak value, but because of increased positional value I think either Pena or Brown could bring a similar return as Tucker.
LikeLiked by 1 person
Just learned the Astros have also interviewed Albert Pujols for the manager role. Does that mean they’ll bring Brad Lidge back as bench coach? 😉
Seriously, it appears the Astros want to name a manager this week, according to ‘sources’.
LikeLike
And Morgan….Astros To Interview Albert Pujols, Morgan Ensberg For Managerial Job – MLB Trade Rumors
LikeLike
Hmm. Okay, so the Astros now have a former player as GM. Another former player (Bagwell) in the front office. It only stands to reason that a former player is sitting in the manager’s chair, right?
Pujols? Ensberg? Ausmus?
LikeLike