Astros’ offseason: A snapshot of the starting pitching

If the 2026 Astros were a three-legged stool of offense, relief pitching, and starting pitching (yes, for this example I am skipping fielding), the short leg of the stool was starting pitching.

In the American League, the 2026 Astros starters had a 4.86 ERA (14th out of 15), threw 774.2 innings (12th), had a 1.40 WHIP (14th), gave up 378 walks (worst in fewer innings than most of the other teams), and gave up 113 HRs (fifth worst, with three teams ahead of them with many more innings pitched).

The Astros had 19 different pitchers start games, though, truth be told, four of those were “opener” starts by relievers. Of the 15 real starters used, 8 ended up with ERAs of 5.00 or higher, and 3 (Spencer Arrighetti, Lance McCullers and Colton Gordon) ended up with other organizations.

It was rather amazing the team was anywhere near the .500 mark, much less making the playoffs as the AL West default champs.

Heading into the off-season, what does the future of the starting staff look like?

Hunter Brown – After missing 2-1/2 months early in the season, Brown came back to start 20 games for the Astros. He was good with a 3.19 ERA, but he was not the Cy Young-ish stud he showed in 2025, and he had only seven starts of six innings or more, culminating in one seven-inning start back in July. Again, he was good but frankly was not the ace the Astros were hoping for. They have two seasons left of control, but will he complete those two seasons here?

Looking forward to 2027….

  • Best case scenario – A return to the 12-9, 2.43 ERA, 5.9 WAR stud of 2025.
  • Worst case scenario – Another uneven and semi-injured season like 2026?

Peter Lambert – His 8-10, 3.82 ERA numbers look pedestrian. But he led the team in wins (8), games started (29), and innings pitched (155.2) – the last two by huge margins. And then there is this. If you remove one start in August where he gave up 9 runs in 3.2 innings – his ERA for the other 28 starts was 3.38. Also, his last win was in July – but in his last 14 winless starts – 10 of them he allowed 2 or fewer runs.

The question with Lambert is …. Will he do this again or was this like Jason Alexander of 2025? The gut feeling is that he is a better pitcher than that, but he also looked like he was struggling at the end of the season as he went way beyond his previous high for innings.

Looking forward to 2027….

  • Best case scenario – A similar performance to 2026, but with more run support and more wins.
  • Worst case scenario – A crash back to earth as he is figured out by the rest of baseball.

Cristian Javier – After finally returning from TJ surgery to start the season – he missed 3 more months with shoulder tightness and soreness. When he returned in July, he roller coastered a bit before hitting his stride in September, going 1-1 with a fine 1.96 ERA. He left his last start somewhat ominously on September 22 after 2 innings, but it was a groin injury, which, while not fun, is not the concern an elbow or shoulder injury would be.

Cristian will be paid $21+ million for 2027.

Looking forward to 2027…

  • Best-case scenario – It is probably too much to ask to get back the Invisiball master of 2022, who went 11-9 with a 2.54 ERA and was part of a regular-season and a World Series no-hitter. But maybe a solid season in that 3 to 3.5 ERA range is doable, especially after seeing an uptick in his pitching in September.
  • Worst case scenario – Arm troubles return, and he ends up being a black hole where $60+ million disappeared into…

Hayden Wesneski – Wesneski was the one returnee from the IL, who really seemed to be all the way back. Starting 11 games down the stretch, he went 6-2 with a 3.25 ERA and did what no other pitcher was doing, which was keeping his pitch count down and innings up, including three seven-inning outings, which for this team was significant.

They still have 3 seasons of control with Wesneski.

Looking forward to 2027…

  • Best case scenario – Wesneski continues his strong end of 2026 and rolls up into a third man in the rotation spot and stays healthy.
  • Worst case scenario – His arm problems return or….he is not that effective, and the league figures him out.

Mike Burrows – Last off-season, the Astros sent prospects Anderson Brito and Jacob Melton to Tampa Bay (in a 3-way trade) and received SP Mike Burrows from the Pirates. They thought they were receiving a pitcher who was pretty solid in 2025 (2-4, 3.95 ERA) in 23 games /19 starts and who was under team control through 2031.

They received a pitcher who was awful in 2026 (4-9, 5.99 ERA) and extremely hittable (10.6 hits / 9 IP and 2 HRs/ 9 IP). Burrows did not pitch enough to “qualify” for pitching stats, but for those  three stats (ERA, Hits/9 IP, HRs/9 IP) – his numbers are worse than any of the qualifiers in the majors.

Looking forward to 2027…

  • Best-case scenario – They unlock his talent and end up with a solid middle-of-the-rotation arm.
  • Worst-case scenario – Burrows does not improve and either remains a bad option in the rotation or becomes a non-option.

Tatsuya Imai – This is the biggest mystery heading into 2027. Will Imai even want to return for 2027? If he returns will he even be used in any useful way in 2027? Can the team make him feel more comfortable and can he psychologically overcome whatever demons were preventing him from pitching up to his talent level.

He showed sparks of good pitching, including throwing 6 no-hit innings on the way to a multi-pitcher no-hitter back in May and solid (but sporadic) effectiveness in his last eight non-starting appearances, where he had a 2.00 ERA out of the bullpen. But he could not be trusted in the rotation as 4 of his 15 starts ended at 1.1 inning or less due mostly to control problems. His 6.8 hits / 9 IP was good. His 6 walks / 9 IP was very bad.

Looking forward to 2027….if he does not opt out of his $18 million contract for each of the next two seasons.

  • Best case scenario – He spends time with pitching guru Brent Strom and perhaps with psychological guru Sigmund Freud V and comes back a confident and controlled starting pitcher.
  • Worst-case scenario – He continues to disappoint with his inconsistency and remains a mop-up pitcher at the back of the bullpen, sopping up $18 million for almost nothing.

Ethan Pecko – Pecko’s 2-0 record and 3.95 ERA disguise the fact that he was so much better as a reliever than a starter. He put up a 5.85 ERA as a starter and a 1.26 ERA as a reliever. The odd part is that his three relief appearances were actually the first one out of the bullpen after a one-inning opener started the game, and he pitched multiple innings like a starter would.

Is he ready to join a rotation next season or is he just a candidate for a long relief spot?

Looking forward to 2027…

  • Best case scenario – Pecko takes a step forward and is able to be a back end of the rotation candidate.
  • Worst case scenario – He is unable to produce as a starter like he does out of the bullpen.

Ronel Blanco – Blanco returned in July 2026 from his TJ surgery in June 2025, but with not as successful results (0-1, 6.68 ERA in 8 games/5 starts) as Hayden Wesneski. With an additional off-season to build back arm strength and accuracy can he find the success he had in 2024 (13-6, 2.80 ERA), when he was arguably the Astros best starter?

Looking forward to 2027….

  • Best case scenario – He channels the 2024 Blanco and rolls into the 2nd or 3rd spot in the rotation.
  • Worst case scenario – At 33 y.o. he is no longer “that” guy and he fades into the sunset.

Brandon Walter – Back in 2025, the lefty came up and threw 9 strong starts – averaging almost 6 innings an outing with a very good 3.35 ERA. Then he followed the parade of Astros pitchers with arm troubles, had TJ surgery late in the season and sat out all of 2026. There was tantalizing talent here, but with the shadow of arm problems looming over his career.

Looking forward to 2027….

  • Best case scenario – Even if he does not grab a job immediately, at some point he steps up and earns a starting rotation spot and shows why they held on to him.
  • Worst case scenario – It never comes back or if it does, he is one of those guys that just can’t stay healthy.

Miguel Ullola – In some ways this seems unlikely after the great job Ullola did in limited appearances at the MLB level out of the bullpen, but he has started 86 games in the minors including 33 at the AAA level. It is a thought.

  • Best case scenario – They take a flyer on the young man and he continues to put the competition away as a starter. (Best scenario part B – he turns into a high leverage late inning beast out of the bullpen).
  • Worst case scenario – Trying to make him a starter messes with his head and he can’t pitch as a starter or a reliever.

Jackson Nezuh – He pitched solidly between AA and AAA in 2026 ending up with a 4-3 record and 3.83 ERA in 26 games / 19 starts. Like many a prospect – he needs better control.

Looking forward to 2027…..

  • Best case scenario – He seasons a bit more at AAA in 2027, places those pitches better and gets a call-up when needed.
  • Worst case scenario – He never finds the plate.

If you look closely at this list, the biggest take away is that the Astros desperately need more solid, dependable starting pitching. That is expensive – either as a free agent or based on what you would have to trade away to get it.

What are your thoughts?

13 responses to “Astros’ offseason: A snapshot of the starting pitching”

  1. It’s a short stool right now.

    I’ve always believed it’s easier to win with a bad offense and good rotation than vice versa. Of course, you want both to be good. But the reality is, there are 9 guys in the batting order and 8 on the field. The ability for any one of them to be the reason you lose is practically none. The starting pitcher though, he is on an island. Yes, he needs the offense to win, but he can sure 100% lose the game himself with or without the offense. Finding 5 guys that won’t lose many games by themselves should be the priority of any baseball team.

    The Astros clearly go into 2027 with a rotation that is patchy and full of guys that have proven, at some point, they can pitch at this level. But they have also proven they can just hand games over at times. I feel confident about Hunter. Everything is there. Pitching is such a finesse project. If you spend all of ST and the start of the season in one head space, and everything is interrupted, it’s hard to stay in it. The best can live in the head space. That’s what Hunter has to find. Once you are out of your head space, the confidence wanes, and you leave pitches where you don’t mean to leave pitches. You struggle hitting the edge you were trying and it’s 3 inches outside.

    Ronel reminded me of a guy that was ready to get back in there. The velocity was certainly there. He may have even gained a tick. I’m guessing that the movement didn’t feel right to him, or his spin rate might have dropped and he couldn’t adjust mid-season to what was happening. Next thing you know, he is in the rotation, and blowing games because the pitch isn’t ending up exactly where he wants.

    This is a recurring thing. Imai probably fits it too. Burrows as well. Pitching is so finesse. There are hundred different things can change from arm slot and angle to where the foot lands to the point of the toe to grips to a million things. But the most important mechanic isn’t learning to pitch with a different elbow after TJ or creating spin, its managing your head space.

    I think Brown, Lambert and Wesneski are a good start. But who knows. If you asked anyone to guess the 2027 rotation in 2024, they might have put a litany of different names that are no longer even with the organization.

    And I certainly don’t think Peter Lambert is Jason Alexander or J.P. France. I think his stuff is major league stuff.

    Like

  2. Good morning, this particular exercise really has me committed to a rebuild, or whatever we want to call it. But alas, I still consider it a pipe dream, or at least a long, long shot. Keep a guy like Wesneski. And Lambert. You hope Javier is healthy. You get Walter back, maybe even before the lockout ends. Perhaps Pecko and Ullola are real options in the pen. You hope Burrows is healthy and can provide innings. If Imai is determined to collect on his contract, you put him to work, and you do it our way this time. He listens and learns from Strom. He learns the third pitch he does not want to throw. And he eats dinner with his teammates. Otherwise he goes home and we’ve got a bit of money to work with.

    Then you trade both Hader and Hunter. And from those two guys we get another batch of young, team controlled more athletic athletes. In that group we’ll also get a couple of young arms depending on who is making the decisions around AC Park.

    Thing is, we actually do have more tradable guys that we had in 2011. And we don’t have to be a 100 loss team in 2027. And we do have a few guys that we want to keep. If the hierarchy of the Astros is committed to real change and not just one more patch job, we can start turning the corner. Another tweak and patch job will tell us who is running the club. And as a senior citizen myself, I think it’s okay to not want a senior citizen running this club.

    So what can we get for Alvarez, Pena, Brown and Hader? I think a positive change in direction.

    Like

  3. Last night it seemed that half the crowd in Tampa Bay was Brew Crew. Tonight it will be like a home game. I’m sure there are folks in Milwaukee that left in the wee hours and hit the road to Florida because they could not get a flight, but could get tickets to tonights game at an approachable price. It’s been since 1957 when Milwaukee last saw a World Series, as the Braves.

    Like

  4. If the Brewers finish this off – it will give me some warm feelings. I was born there – and my parents were big fans of the Braves and the great Hank Aaron. The Braves moving to Atlanta didn’t upset them as much as others in the family because we had already made our own moves to the south as a family.

    I know my cousin Bob will be happy about this – a very loooong time coming.

    Like

  5. I think you guys cursed the Brewers. I don’t care who wins the game, but they’re both interesting franchises to talk about. Both follow the model we seem to be supporting – trade you best players who aren’t going to sign under market extensions while you can for prospects.

    Like

  6. The word is floating around Houston right now. The R-word. Rebuild.

    Look, no one wants to admit the golden era is fading, but if a reset is truly on the horizon, I have one major reservation that keeps me up at night: I simply don’t know that I trust the people in the room right now to pull it off.

    When you look across Major League Baseball at teams that master the art of the pivot, you always point to the Tampa Bay Rays. They are the gold standard of decision-making. They don’t just evaluate what they have; they possess an eerie, unmatched ability to know exactly when they’ve squeezed the best years out of a star, ensuring they never overpay for past performance.

    Take the legendary David Price trade tree as the ultimate example. From 2007 until the 2014 trade deadline, the Rays paid Price roughly $30 million. In return, they got a staggering 21.3 WAR. After they traded him? The rest of baseball paid him a whopping $250 million over the next nine seasons for just 19 more WAR! Price didn’t suddenly become a bad pitcher after leaving Tampa—he was still pretty good—but the Rays got his absolute peak at a premium discount, while everyone else paid a king’s ransom for him to be good, not great.

    But the real magic of a competent front office isn’t just saving money; it’s the cascading value of the returns. Look at what the Rays turned that single David Price asset into over the next decade:

    • The Initial Return: Tampa traded Price for Drew Smyly, Willy Adames, and Nick Franklin.
    • The Smyly Branch: Smyly gave them 3.8 WAR before Tommy John surgery hit, but they quickly flipped him to Seattle for Mallex Smith, Carlos Vargas, and Ryan Yarbrough. Yarbrough gave them four solid years as a reliable swingman. Mallex Smith provided two strong seasons (4.8 WAR) before being flipped for Mike Zunino (who eventually mashed 33 homers in a 3.7 WAR season) and pieces that later morphed into valuable bullpen depth like Matt Wisler.
    • The Adames Branch: Willy Adames gave Tampa 7.5 WAR over three seasons before they traded him to Milwaukee. The return? Drew Rasmussen, who has been an absolute absolute monster, racking up nearly 16 WAR and counting, alongside JP Feyereisen’s solid bullpen years.

    To recap: The Rays got 21.3 WAR out of David Price, then masterfully spun him into about 40 WAR of total organizational value (and counting). Meanwhile, the rest of the league paid him a quarter of a billion dollars for half the production.

    That is the level of elite asset management, scouting, and ruthless efficiency required to successfully tear down a roster and build it back up without sinking into a decade of irrelevance.

    And that brings us back to Daikin. If the Astros are going to jumpstart a great reset, we need a front office capable of executing that exact kind of chess match. Right now, I look at our current leadership, and I just don’t see it. Until this front office proves they can find the next generation of value before the cliff arrives, standing pat—even on a shaky foundation—might be a safer bet than letting them engineer a rebuild.

    Like

    • You’re right. The Astros trade I always go back to was giving up Halama, Guillen, and Garcia to get 11 starts out of Randy Johnson. I still think it was worth it and had they been able to sign him for an extremely large contract his performance in Arizona indicates it would have been worth paying the man. But there are some that fizzle more than pop. We sent Roy Oswalt to Philly for JA Happ, Anthony Gose, and Jonathon Villar. Then we sent Hunter Pence to Philly for Jon Singleton, Jarred Cosart, Josh Zeid, and a PTBNL (Domingo Santana). There were a handful of contributions from those guys and we did flip Cosart to Miami later in a significant trade that also lost us Kike Hernandez, but it would be hard to argue either of those really set us up for long term success. So hopefully whoever does take the GM job has a better crystal ball than the one they’ve been using in Houston.

      Like

  7. The Rays played quite a bit of uncharacteristically sloppy baseball over the past week. The Brewers have brought a World Series Championship to Milwaukee for the first time since 1957. The better baseball team won.

    Finally, hopefully we can get down to figuring out what the Astros are going to do. I wonder if they know what they are going to do? Bloggy, yeah, some of us here are looking for a full rebuild. But I think few of us think it will happen as long as Crane/Bagwell are still wearing the pants. Regardless of who wants to be the new Astro GM, he’s simply not going to have the luxury of full decision making. Those Luhnow era times are long gone.

    Nevertheless, I’m really interested to see if our in house experts continue to screw up the Astro organization or somehow find a middle ground and collectively get us moving in the right direction.

    For me though, I’m firmly in the bold moves camp.

    Like

  8. Don’t now this guy, but apparently the Astros have identified the Brewers’ Matt Kleine as the guy they want for GM.

    One of the the things the Astros have apparently been looking for in a new GM is someone who knows how to manage lower payrolls. Hmmm.

    Like

    • Chip, seems he’s been the odds on favorite. Sounds better than Rizzo. Tough job for Kleine though considering all that varied dynamics that come with the Astros.

      Like

      • Yes, he’s been on the short list for sure…but now it seems like he IS the list. He’s a young guy…only 40…so it will be interesting to see how he handles the ‘older’ crowd in the front office.

        If, indeed, he is the guy, he’ll have about a month to get his house in order before owners shut the doors.

        Like

Leave a Reply