ChipalattAwards for 2025

I’ve put this off as long as I could, but it is time to see who should be awarded for the Astros first non-playoff season since 2016.

Here is a quick stat chart of the Astros’ pitchers in 2025.

NameGmWLSvsIPERAWHIPKs/9 IPBAAOBPAOPSABAbipIR/ IS
Framber Valdez31131101923.661.2458.8.238.308.667.299N/A
Hunter Brown311290185.12.431.02510.201.271.589.264N/A
Lance McCullers1625055.16.511.8079.9.269.392.854.3270/0
Cristian Javier8240374.621.2708.3.230.306.665.279N/A
Colton Gordon20641865.341.4197.5.293.329.872.3120/0
Jason Alexander1442171.13.661.2487.6.247.306.731.2730/0
Spencer Arrighetti715035.15.351.4157.6.229.340.752.250N/A
Hayden Wesneski6130324.501.0948.2.240.279.758.256N/A
Ronel Blanco934048.14.101.1798.9.210.288.669.244N/A
Brandon Walter913053.23.350.9328.7.225.252.673.254N/A
A.J. Blubaugh11310321.690.8759.8.152.226.565.1533/0
J.P. France210042.251.00011.3.143.250.464.2220/0
Josh Hader48622852.22.050.85413.158.232.574.2083/0
Bryan Abreu70347712.281.15513.3.196.291.567.30922/6
Bryan King68542682.781.0449.1.233.273.649.27623/1
Steven Okert6832171.23.010.89310.5.181.242.528.24138/9
Kaleb Ort49221464.891.3489.6.213.323.719.25019/3
Bennett Sousa4451450.22.841.02610.5.204.263.594.27516/3
Enyel de los Santos2230022.14.031.2549.7.265.311.817.30919/5
Tayler Scott1801018.17.361.9098.3.296.409.944.3407/3
Craig Kimbrel13010112.451.36413.1.225.326.701.3181/0
Hector Neris1201011.25.401.80011.6.283.382.947.3452/1

Note – I added the IR (Inherited runners) / IS (Inherited runners who scored) stat for the relievers.

Here is a comparison between 2024 and 2025 for Astros starting pitchers:

YearWIPERAWHIPBAAKsBBsHRs
202459 (4th in AL)880.2 (4th)3.81 (T5th)1.24 (8th).233 (2nd)887 (2nd)326 (14th)111 (4th)
202550 (T-8th in AL)862.2 (6th)3.97 (T-7th)1.23 (T-6th).238 (T-3rd)857 (2nd)284 (10th)118 (7th)

There were a lot of parallels between the two seasons and the results were very similar as in both seasons the team had to overcome almost a complete loss of rotations twice. The starters and the bullpen allowed the Astros to have as much success as they experienced in 2025.

Top Starting Pitcher 2025 – Hunter Brown – There is really no doubt here unless you base your decision on the old, back of the baseball card stat – Wins.  Beyond that he was really brilliant in almost all facets of pitching, especially his slash against stats – .201 BAA/.271 OBPA/ .589 OPSA.

Runner-up 2025 – Framber Valdez – Yes, I hate to do it, but he had the most wins and the most IPs of any starter and there is just no one else in the neighborhood.

2025 Special Recognition – A.J. Blubaugh – In his 11 appearances he went 3-1 with a 1.69 ERA and a brilliant slash against of .152 BAA/ .226 OBPA/ .565 OPSA. I’m almost ready to give him the Runner-up spot.

Top Starting Pitcher 2024 – Ronel Blanco / Runner-up – Framber Valdez

2024 Special Recognition – Hunter Brown and Yusei Kikuchi

Here is a comparison between 2024 and 2025 for Astros relief pitchers:

YearWSavesIPERAWHIPBAAKsBBsHRs
202429 (T7th in AL)43 (T6th)551.1 (13th)3.66 (4th)1.25 (7th).228 (T7th)592 (8th)218 (8th)72 (T8th)
202537 (T-2nd in AL)45 (T2nd)579.1 (12th)3.70 (5th)1.22(1st).224 (1st)647 (1st)224 (6th)81 (T12th)

Even with Josh Hader missing the end of the season, injuries to Sousa and Ort and having one of their best relievers of 2024 (Tayler Scott) melt down, the bullpen was very solid for the majority of the season.

Top Relief Pitcher of 2025 – Josh Hader – He was really earning that big salary with a great season including only one blown save. Too bad he got injured also.

2025 Runner-up – Bryan Abreu – He struggled a bit in replacing Hader as closer, but his numbers for the season were excellent.

Special Recognition 2025 – Bryan King and Steven Okert – These two were both extremely dependable and threw in 68 games apiece.

Top Relief Pitcher of 2024 – Tayler Scott / Runner-up – Bryan Abreu

2024 Special Recognition – Bryan King and Kaleb Ort

Here is a quick stat chart of the Astros’ position players in 2025.

NameABsRunsDblsHRsRBIsBBsKsBAOBPOPSBAbip
Carlos Correa20023106211945.290.355.785.349
Jose Altuve5888024267755109.265.329.771.283
Christian Walker5857224278840177.238.297.717.291
Cam Smith441552195143137.236.312.671.320
Yainer Diaz542562520702095.256.284.701.277
Jeremy Pena493683017623593.304.363.840.345
Jesus Sanchez1462194121340.199.269.611.245
Victor Caratini344351412462365.259.324.728.282
Mauricio Dubon36843217332442.241.289.644.255
Yordan Alvarez1651786272833.273.367.797.295
Isaac Paredes378531520535076.254.352.809.268
Ramon Urias9465310628.223.267.640.281
Jacob Melton70700726.157.234.419.268
Cesar Salazar13000102.231.375.606.273
Taylor Trammell1351572121741.197.296.630.270
Zach Cole4792411520.255.327.880.348
Brice Matthews426049220.167.222.675.167
Jake Meyers3435315324531.292.354.727.353
Brendan Rodgers1151242111146.191.266.544.294
Chas McCormick10013515931.210.279.569.290
Zach Dezenzo981762101137.245.321.688.373
Cooper Hummel87100371430.172.301.577.222
Jacob Melton707007629.157.234.419.268
Zack Short509227418.220.291.671.300
Shay Whitcomb324011010.125.125.344.143

Here is a comparison between 2024 and 2025 for Astros position players.

YearBAOBPOPSRunsHRsSBsKsBBs
2024.262 (1st).322 (2nd).740 (4th)740 (5th)190 (5th)93 (10th)1176 (2nd)448 (13th)
2025250 (6th).315 (7th).714 (7th)686 (8th)182 (T-10th)85 (11th)1301 (3rd)471 (13th)

After dropping a half run scored per game between 2023 and 2024, the Astros continued to droop – with their scoring dropping another 1/3 of a run per game in 2025. Of course, when you look up there and see Yordan with only 17 runs scored, 6 HRs and 27 RBIs and knowing that Kyle Tucker and Alex Bregman played elsewhere this season – it is not that surprising.

Top Positional Player of 2025 – Jeremy Pena – Like Hunter Brown this was not really close as Pena had his best season of a good career and showed a lot more eye at the plate. That slash of .304 BA/ .363 OBP/ .840 OPS was excellent tied to another fine year at shortstop.

2025 Runner-up – Isaac Paredes – Straight away, if Paredes had not missed so much time with the hamstring (plus coming back as damaged goods) the Astros make the playoffs. He did an excellent job of working the pitchers – it seemed like half the time he was at a 3-2 count and when the pitcher gave in he did something with it.

2025 – Special Recognition – Zach Cole – It was only a small cup of coffee, but Cole was one of the few call-ups on the position side who looked like he belonged.

Top Positional Player of 2024 – Yordan AlvarezRunners-up – Jose Altuve and Yainer Diaz.

 2024 Special Recognition – Kyle Tucker

2025 Biggest Surprise (Positive) – Jason Alexander – You just don’t expect a 32-year-old, who had been hit hard in his two previous shots at the majors to show up and become a critical part of the rotation down the stretch. But he did.

2025 Runner-up – A.J. Blubaugh – After a bit of a shaky start he settled down and one can only wonder what would have happened if he had started the games that Lance McCullers Jr. started.

2024 Biggest Surprise (Positive) – Ronel Blanco / Runner-up – Tayler Scott

2025 Biggest Disappointment – Christian Walker – I did not think we would get 30 year old Walker, but I sure did not expect Jose Abreu 2.0

2025 Runner-up – Tayler Scott – He was arguably the Astros best, most consistent reliever in 2024, but he fell off the cliff in 2025. It may have been more of a surprise than a disappointment.

2024 Biggest Disappointment – Chas McCormick/ Runner-up – Justin Verlander

Some Comments on Season Stats

  • Special recognition to Bryan King inheriting 23 runners for the season and only letting one score – in his last game of the year.
  • If you had 10 guesses, would you have guessed that the pitcher with the third most saves behind Hader and Abreu in 2025 with 4 would be Bennett Sousa?
  • That 12-9 record for Hunter Brown in a top 3 Cy Young season is bothersome. But…back in 1987, Nolan Ryan led the league with a 2.76 ERA, but sported an impossible to fathom 8-16 record.
  • Getting Carlos Correa may have set up the Astros with some real lineup challenges with so many infielders around in 2026. But he put up very solid stats in his short time back.
  • Chas McCormick might have made the most disappointing list, but since he was on the 2024 list for that – it does not make much sense to give it to him again.
  • I know he struggled in the second half but still need to give kudos to Cam Smith for surviving a tough situation. He did OK playing at a totally new position at such a young age. He can only go up.

As usual, it is your turn to comment. Any awards you disagree with? Any new ones you want to award? Any stats strike you?

10 responses to “ChipalattAwards for 2025”

  1. The awards topic remains my toughest when our club is so tough to watch.

    But alas, some guys had excellent seasons. Hunter got a top three for Cy Young. That was impressive. Hader, a great season until he went down. Abreu until his job description changed. Pena at the plate. Issac until he went down. The pen in general.

    But I refuse to recognize Framber. He mailed it in. He showed his lack in depth of character. I feel bad for Cam actually. He was a victim of Dana’s inability to provide a major league line up to Joe, from the very start of the season. I hope Cam is as tough mentally as everyone claims.

    From Sanchez, to Trammel, to Brendon I forget his last name at second, Dezenzo until he went down, Chas, Cooper, Frenchie, Melton, Zack Short, Whitcomb, Corona, Singleton, Brice, Guillorme, Diaz, Walker and others, Dana just could not find a bat for this club, even at the deadline. Correction. We did get Carlos for the next three years, which could be ugly too. Little wonder why our hitting coaches had to go.

    I was most impressed with all of the arms that helped this club stay in the race for so long. Alexander, whom I don’t expect much more from going forward, Walter, Gusto, whom I think will be a pretty good ML pitcher, Gordon, who I think the league has figured out. Blubaugh maybe, and we sure could use 125 innings approaching what he gave us late in the season.

    I really hope this club looks significantly different by Opening Day. Again, younger and more athletic. That will be tough with Correa and Altuve and Walker and even Paredes if he’s still compromised by that hamstring not getting surgically repaired. Yordan in left will be an issue. Station to station is old news baseball. Right now, it’s our game.

    Like

    • Have to agree with you daveb –

      • Maybe I should have just not picked a runner-up at starting pitcher. After Hunter and Framber – nobody had more than 14 starts or 6 wins – just hard to award on that basis. I should have left it blank like Framber left us staring at a blank.
      • I saw enough talent with Cam that I think he will turn it around – especially if he gets a little better guidance at the dish.
      • The inability to develop the hitting was really disturbing. Zach Cole looked good – but very small sample and he was brought up on fire. The league may find that hole in the swing. Dezenzo was decent but then got hurt.
      • The one thing with Blubaugh was that .153 BAbip – that is an unsustainably low number – the average on that usually runs around .300. And Alexander could be a Tayler Scott waiting to happen. But all these arms kept the team in the hunt.
      • The team needs a little injury luck this coming year – they sure have earned it after two seasons of pure hell.

      Like

    • They would have to sign him to a minor league contract – no room on the 40.

      He pitched well in a small minor league sample and in a small sample at Mexican Winter league this off-season. With Detroit last year he gave up 2 runs in 2.1 innings – pretty meaningless.

      The Astros do know his medical history – not sure if that matters.

      Might be worth kicking the tires on him.

      Like

  2. I don’t want to try to change anyone’s mind on Framber. He was really good in the first half and fell apart in the second. In August he had starts at Boston, NYY, and DET that didn’t go well. He was mediocre in a few others. In the first half his only real bad start was at STL. He was definitely our second best starting pitcher. I’m not bringing him back unless he takes the QO.

    1st Half: 10-4, 2.75ERA, 121IP, 37 ER, 8HR, 41BB, 125K, 1.124WHIP. 9.3K/9
    2nd Half: 3-7, 5.20ERA, 72 IP, 41 ER, 7HR, 27BB, 62K, 1.451WHIP, 7.9K/9

    Home: 6-4, 2.58ERA, 94.1IP, 27ER, 32BB, 102K, 1.155WHIP, 9.7K/9

    Away: 7-7, 4.70ERA, 97.2IP, 51ER, 36BB, 85K, 1.331WHIP, 7.8K/9

    Regarding hitters, I like guys who get on base. I don’t like guys who don’t. Cam Smith had a really rough 2nd half like a lot of guys. Overall, he had a .312OBP despite only posting a .236BA. That gives me a lot of hope for the future. Yes, Walker, Dubon, and Diaz were the only regular players with worse OBP…but that should give you some hope as well. The first of the three is probably cooked. The second is not a hitter. The third has to improve next year, right? As such, I’m talking myself into the Correa trade because all we gave up was money and they weren’t spending that money on a bonafide ace this winter anyhow. Ideally a new training staff will help keep Correa and Alvarez on the field. That alone would improve the offense considerably.

    Like

    • Sarge, I suppose that move was inevitable. We needed to protect Ullola. But that keeps Dubon, an excellent fielder, but a terrible hitter, in the line up far too often. I don’t think any new hitting coach will convince Frenchie to be more selective. Urias has a 104 OPS+ lifetime. Dubon an 87. Urias has an 11.2 WAR over 541 games. Dubon a 7.3 over 664 games. Urias has a GG too. And he would have been cheaper. I believe he’s a better baseball player all around. I’ll feel much better if somehow the Astros pull off a deal for Brendan Donovan.

      Like

    • This is very much a surprise to me.

      On one hand, we know Duby is prolific in the OF as well as the IF. On the other, Urias is a slightly better hitter and can also play all over the IF. He probably doesn’t handle SS as well as Duby does, and that might be a part of it, but I think the Astros have to bank on 155 game from Jeremy Pena, if you aren’t getting that next year you are probably not stepping forward anyway.

      No matter how good he is defensively, I can’t imagine a player with a career .688 OPS with just a .644 last year is going to get 6.5-7M next year. I’ve always been a fan and a supporter of Duby, he is just a silky smooth baseballer. I think he has potential to be a better hitter as he enters his prime and gets stronger because he has the natural talent. While he is difficult to strike out, he is also difficult to walk. If he wants to force the pitches that will give him an opportunity to be a better hitter statistically, he is going to have to learn to lay off pitches out of the zone, but that seems to be a common theme across this roster.

      Like

    • We’ll find out what Framber is made of this year. Astro fans always supported him, even when he freaked out from time to time. I don’t think he’ll experience the same degree of graciousness going forward. But I think I’d rather he be successful than not.

      Like

Leave a comment