Coming out of an off-season where some free agent contracts had lots of zeroes in them and we are talking TONS of them, lets take a look at the positional player who has been the best (So Far) for his new team. For the moment we will call him Player X and we will look at his numbers against a bunch of the other top free agents signed this season. (All stats through Tuesday 5-14-19).
Player X – 55 hits (tied for 1st in his league), .335 BA (1st), .379 OBP (16th),.964 OPS (7th), 26 runs (Tied for 15th), 10 HRs (Tied for 13th) 31 RBIs (9th). Signed for 2 years/ $32 million
Bryce Harper – .219 BA / .370 OBP (17th)/ .802 OPS / 32 hits / 25 runs / 7 HRs / 25 RBIs – only his .370 OBP is in the top 20 in the NL. Signed for 13 yrs/ $330 MM
Manny Machado – .265 BA / .335 OBP/ .806 OPS / 41 hits / 23 runs / 9 HRs (19th) / 23 RBIs – only his 9 HRs is in the top 20 in the NL. Signed for 10 yrs / $300 MM
Yasmani Grandal – .265 BA / .353 OBP / .807 OPS / 35 hits / 21 runs / 7 HRs / 19 RBIs – none in the top 20 in his league (but solid numbers for a catcher). Signed for 1 yr / $18.25 MM
A.J. Pollock – .223 BA / .287 OBP / .617 OPS / 23 hits / 15 runs / 2 HR / 14 RBIs – Nothing in the top 20 in his league and on the IL. Signed for 4 yrs / $55 MM
Andrew McCutchen – .232 BA / .363 OBP / .751 OPS / 36 hits / 28 runs (14th) / 5 HR / 14 RBIs – Only runs scored is in the top 20 in the NL – Signed for 3 yrs / $50 MM
Josh Donaldson – .254 BA / .379 OBP (15th) / .849 OPS / 34 hits / 22 runs / 6 HRs / 19 RBIs – Only his OBP is in the top 20 in the NL – Signed for 1 yr / $23 MM
Wilson Ramos – .231 BA / .299 OBP / .604 OPS / 28 hits / 15 runs / 2 HRs / 23 RBIs – None in the Top 20 in the NL – Signed for 2 yrs / $19 MM
Marwin Gonzalez – .232 BA / .314 OBP / .666 OPS / 29 hits / 14 runs / 4 HRs / 13 RBIs – None in the top 20 in his league – Signed for 2 yrs / $21 MM
Nelson Cruz – .270 BA / .354 OBP / .862 OPS / 34 hits / 19 runs / 7 HRs / 22 RBIs – None in the top 20 in his league – Currently sitting out a few games with a wrist injury – Signed for 1 yr / $14.3 MM
Jed Lowrie – .Has not played yet with a knee injury – Expected back in June – Signed for 3 yrs / $30 MM
Daniel Murphy – .200 BA / .269 OBP / .652 OPS / 12 hits / 10 runs / 2 HRs / 13 RBIs – None in the top 20 in his league – Missed time with a broken finger – Signed for 2 yrs / $24 MM
Brian Dozier – .192 BA / . 295 OBP / .618 OPS / 25 hits / 12 runs / 5 HRs / 7 RBIs – None in the top 20 in his league – Signed for 1 yr / $9 MM
D.J. LeMahieu – .333 BA (2nd in AL) / .384 OBP (13th) / . 836 OPS / 45 hits (16th) / 22 runs / 2 HRs / 21 RBIs – Top 20 in BA, OBP and hits in AL – Signed for 2 yrs / $21 MM
Mike Moustakas – .248 BA / .315 OBP / .825 OPS / 38 hits / 22 runs / 10 HR (13th) / 27 RBIs (18th) – Top 20 in HRs and RBIs in NL – Signed for 1 yr / $10 MM
Nick Markakis – .293 BA (18th) / .388 OBP (13th) / .841 OPS / 44 hits / 26 runs (18th) / 4 HRs / 23 RBIs – Top 20 in BA, OBP and runs in the NL – Signed for 1 yr / $6 MM
Adam Jones – .276 BA / .341 OBP / .850 OPS / 45 hits (18th) / 21runs / 9 HRs (19th) / 25 RBIs – Top 20 in hits and HRs in the NL – Signed for 1 yr / $3 MM
While most of these players have been solid or at least decent, while someone like LeMahieu has been very good in an injury ravaged Yankees’ lineup, and while guys like Markakis and Jones have been real bargains, the new positional free agent, who has really shown in every category is Player X. And Player X is ……the Astros’ Michael Brantley. Player X is probably a good nickname for a guy who has been good to very good throughout his career, but usually overshadowed by teammates.
He has been a critical cog in an Astros’ lineup that is returning to the beast days of 2017. He is making the players ahead and behind him better hitters and gives the team the middle of the order left handed bat they have been lacking. The Astros have 3 of the top 9 BAs in the AL (Brantley, Josh Reddick and George Springer) and 4 of the top 10 in OPS (Brantley, Springer, Alex Bregman and Carlos Correa).
YIE (Yes, It’s Early) but a big chunk of the Astros MLB best 29-15 record is resting on an offensive explosion led by their new left fielder. Brantley will no doubt cool off along the way, but don’t be surprised if he surpasses his career best 20 HRs and 97 RBIs in the middle of this lineup. Especially if Jose Altuve comes back healthy and comes back as the 2017 MVP Jose Altuve.
Player X may not be an under the radar star after this season.
CHIPALATTA 
Player “X” is a big reason for this year’s success as you pointed out. I seem to remember that I said he was going to be a big contributor in a previous post early in the year (but I might be wrong). Anyway, how’s SD and Philly feeling about their high priced off season acquisitions. Maybe this insanity will stop due to that. I know Springer will command a high price but I trust JL will do the right thing. And I would think, George would much rather stay here then play elsewhere. After all, money isn’t everything.
LikeLiked by 1 person
Isn’t Player “X” George’s new best friend?
LikeLike
According to the stats at Fangraphs, these are the players and their positions that comprise the best lineup in baseball:
Springer RF
Altuve 2B
Bregman 3B
Brantley DH
Correa SS
Reddick LF
Diaz 1B
Chirinos C
Marisnick CF
The lowest wRC+ in that group is Diaz who sits at 112 in that particular stat. That means he has been 12% better than the average major leaguer at the plate. He also has the best defensive stats at 1B this season of the 3 players who have played there.
LikeLiked by 1 person
Just looked up Diaz on baseball reference and they say he’s (6′-1″) tall. Does that seem right?
He started off slow but really has been a spark plug lately.
LikeLike
I think Diaz is close to 6″-1″ because when you watch him run he has a nice long stride, which we didn’t notice for the first week or two because he wasn’t running the bases much.
My take on Player X, Player Y(as in Y not make me your catcher?) and Player Z(as in DiaZZ) is they are having so much fun playing for this team, that it is affecting their abilities to the positive. They are all playing better than last season.
LikeLike
Yeah, Diaz runs very well. That’s a pleasant surprise.
LikeLike
Wonder how the Phillies fans feel about Harper now…
LikeLike
As long as Philly is in first place, they will probably cut him some slack. If they start to fade, look out.
LikeLike
What he [George Springer] said: “I think it’s an honor to wear an Astros jersey. To play on the road and see Astros fans everywhere in all different walks of life is something special to me. I know the guys in this clubhouse are very close with the community. This is the best place to play. I love it here.”
What he [George Springer] meant: “I think it’s an honor to wear an Astros jersey. To play on the road and see Astros fans everywhere in all different walks of life is something special to me. I know the guys in this clubhouse are very close with the community. This is the best place to play. I love it here.”
LikeLike
Ah! Say what you mean and mean what you say!
LikeLike
On a side bar, Alvarez is putting up insane Historical numbers, .410 17, and 53, Good lord!
LikeLiked by 1 person
You can say that again!
LikeLike
On a side bar, Alvarez is putting up insane historical numbers, .410 . 17 and 53 Good Lord!
LikeLike
There was a long article about Player X and his father in paper couple weeks ago. They’re tight. Everybody is different but I like his seriousness and way he keeps his head down. That quality can only play well against some of the more boisterous personalities on the team. This is Houston after all, so let’s hope the ‘Stros are just one more chemical plant, without the pollution.
LikeLike
If Brantley stays healthy, he’s a great deal. Next year about this time, we might be looking to tack on a couple of additional years. It’s hard to say who exactly will be playing the outfield for our Astros in 2021. George? Alvarez? Brantley? Straw? Tucker? Jake? Beer Man? I think figuring out a way to keep Springer is paramount. Assuming Reddick is gone, losing George would leave us with a significantly less athletic outfield.
Every time I revisit the Harper lifetime deal, I smile. If he’s not Babe Ruth, that Philly crowd will eventually turn on him. But that dumb club was not forced to give all that money to a guy who averages 26 homers a year, has only reached 100 RBI’s once, who hits .276 lifetime and has an OPS under .900. All good numbers sure, but not a third of a billion worth.
Same thing for Macado. An .821 lifetime OPS. 100 RBI’s once. .336 OBP.
Based on these numbers, George’s agent will be looking for a lot more than we’ll be able to afford. I know Springer is a joyful guy who loves playing baseball with the guys he’s playing with. But at the end of the day, I don’t think we’re going to get a significant hometown discount for his services down the road.
LikeLiked by 1 person
I watched “Moneyball” again this week. I would love to see the algorithm (or whatever) that JL uses to determine the dollar value of players. And before someone pipes up from the cheap seats. “NO, I would not understand it.”
And that would go for Player X, and Y and Z and probably AA, AB, etc.
LikeLike
Player X was there just now. Did u see it?
LikeLike
-Porcello’s own efficiency might have led to his demise. If not for the low pitch count, Cora wouldn’t have left him in there.
-It’s the little things that count. Martinez is no longer an average outfielder and he looked terrible on Reddick’s short sac fly. He did not set himself up for a throw because he didn’t think Brantley would try to score. Sometimes you can outsmart yourself by thinking you can get away with sticking a bad outfielder out there. If Betts is in RF that run doesn’t score.
– So, This Good Jake has lasted through spring training, through April and half of May. A good hitting Jake Marisnick changes a lot.
LikeLiked by 3 people
I gotta admit I had to go outside when Asuna walked Benintendi. He was waiting for Betts to come to the plate to get them in. I exhaled when my husband told me we got out of it. I have a feeling Corbin is going to get worn out tomorrow night. The one guy who really needs to step up is Correa, he’s hitting clean up for a reason. Forgot to tell ya’ll Springer’s sister couldn’t pronounce George, so she gave him his nick name….”Geeg”!
LikeLike
It’s nice seeing J.D. out in right. Hopefully we’ll get a chance to exploit him again over the weekend. The Sox are trying to find nine live bats to put in the line up, but they’ve got Jackie Bradley hitting .153 on the season, so he sat. They used Nunez at DH last night. He came in hitting .191 and finished at .181. Their other two bench guys are hitting .111 and .200. They’ve got holes, at least for now. Conversely, our fourth outfielder is arguably the best defensive outfielder in the league, and is hitting.
But what I find most remarkable is that the Sox have already used 21 pitchers in this young season. Hector Velazquez, the guy starting tonight threw 63 pitches last time out, his longest outing of the season. I think we can get to him and give our young guy some breathing room.
LikeLike
It would appear that these are evenly matched teams. And if the Astros and the Red Sox only played each other for the entire season, both their records would be 81-81.
LikeLike
45, I think they will improve, but right now, I also think we’ve got the better squad. Let’s take advantage of them!
LikeLiked by 1 person
Anyone know what’s up with Whitley, 10.48 ERA after last night?
LikeLiked by 1 person
For the first time in his life, he’s getting his ass kicked. Maybe, at age 21, he’s not yet ready to face quality hitting.
LikeLike
But he really has not been entirely untouchable throughout his minor league career. We should not be considering him an automatic at this point regardless of what the experts say.
LikeLike
Agreed. Too early to count on him or count him out.
LikeLike
Someone mentioned yesterday that Teoscar Hernandez has been sent down. I was checking up on Ramon Laureano a bit ago. He’s hitting .228 with a .285 OBP with 10 walks and 51 K’s. Has the real Ramon stood up?
LikeLike
Would it make anyone feel better if I said that Josh Hader was batting .000?
LikeLiked by 2 people
Say it isn’t so!!
LikeLike
The game today is on regular Fox.
LikeLike
So the announcers will be all things Boston, all the time…
LikeLike
If the Gulf Coast was only treated by the West or East Coasts by national announcers…..
LikeLike
Sorry – If the Gulf Coast was only treated LIKE the West or East Coasts by national announcers
LikeLiked by 1 person
We could win the 2019 World Series and fix that, Dan.
LikeLike
Pressly set the MLB record with 39 consecutive appearances against the team that originally drafted him. Kimbrel who used to be the Red Sox closer held the record – but I think he set it with the Braves
LikeLike
Wow, I just found the game on real TV out here in the boondocks! Maybe tonight is the night that Nephew finds his bat. Good start!
LikeLike
He’s got a chance to double his RBI total for the year.
LikeLike
How ’bout that Josh James!! Corbin Martin had a bad case of nerves, but still he didn’t let the game get away from him. *10* games in a row sure does feel good! They left waaay too many on base….daveb nephew had a pretty good game tonight.
LikeLiked by 1 person
This team is spoiling old Dan P. I love the early scoring – puts the other team on their heels and in a big hole.
Nice to see James get the win after another solid appearance.
LikeLike
I loved what Corbin Martin did tonight. From the very beginning of the game the umpire was squeezing both pitchers. After the Astros got the lead he kept squeezing Martin and gave an extra three inches of strike zone to the Red Sox. Still, the Astros beat the Red Sox and the ump.
LikeLiked by 1 person
I got a kick out of the Fox announcers in the first inning of Saturday night’s game. With the Astros knocking the ball off the wall, all we were hearing about was how great the outfield of the Red Sox was.
If the Astros were ever to make a big statement, it would be today, with Miley going against Sale.
LikeLiked by 2 people
Yes – the Astros were “lucky” the Red Sox weren’t catching those lasers.
You mean how the Red Sox were lucky catching OF lasers in the playoffs last year? Or not even catching one but being rewarded for it?
LikeLiked by 1 person
Josh James gets my game MVP. Corbin got a whole lot of experience last night. And he hung in there too. Just has to be a bit more careful at expressing his exasperation with the guy calling balls and strikes. Nice to get a win in Boston on a night when our guys were not very tidy on the bases. I’ve never seen Stassi look dumb before, although he does not have a lot of experience standing on third base. I was feeling pretty good about watching the game on FOX last night. Cable went out in the 7th inning. I don’t expect to have it back on today. Out in this neck of the woods, faults are dealt with Monday to Friday only, if you’ve lucky.
LikeLiked by 1 person
We are here in East Texas and there were storms in the area. And our Fox Channel ONLY went out in the 7th last night.
LikeLike
Stat of the day, only 2 teams in the history of baseball have 2 10 game winning streaks before the end of MAY . 2019 Astro’s and the 1955 Dodgers!
LikeLiked by 1 person
Some thoughts:
– Player X quietly did what he does – three hits, scored a run, knocked in a run.
– James has turned things around and could be a very important multi-inning weapon during the season
– I was expecting Stassi to try and score on the fly to center (did not see if he had a stop sign), but Marisnick shouldn’t be headed for an occupied base
– Even with that out on the bases it was nice to see him get a couple hits and he almost had a monster HR one time AB, just a little too quick
– What the heck is this offense like if White starts stroking and Altuve comes back and is Altuve once agains?
– It’s hard to comprehend Sale getting 17 Ks in only 7 innings (last time out). I hope our team is able to do a better job of getting contact off him
– The announcers were sure hoping the Red Sox would get back in that game, but the Astros would let them score and then come back to extend it a run again
– Maybe the Astros can work Sale, get him out of the game by the 6th inning and beat up on the Sox bullpen
LikeLiked by 1 person
Dan, speaking of “quietly,” you were “quite” on target with your last two features, George Springer and “X.” Do you have a pipeline?
LikeLike
Yes – you can rely on my prescient pipeline to always be accurate. (Do not look at the post where I called McHugh the new ace…)
LikeLiked by 1 person
You know me. I am not one of those guys who lament players moving on to other teams. So this is not one of those “I told you so” moments. I just was looking at today’s schedule and probable starting pitchers.
Fiers, Thornton, Folty, Musgrove and Morton are all starting today.
Go, Astros!
LikeLiked by 1 person
The good news is that Sale should be done after 6. But we’ve given the Sox 2 of their 3 runs today. I guess it makes keeping the streak going a bit more interesting.
LikeLike
In other news…
My 85 year old father-in-law who was married for 62 years and has been a widower for 2 years is engaged!!!
Not sure what to say other than we love his fiancée.
LikeLiked by 1 person
That’s great Dan!
Separately, Jake kind of looked like the real Jake this weekend. Totally flummoxed by the breaking staff, even when it was getting ready to hit him. Oh well.
LikeLike
Not surprised that Springer left the game with back stiffness. He looked like he over torqued it a few games ago and has looked uncomfortable a few times since
LikeLike
Pingback: Baseball Blogs Weigh In: Giolito, Harper, Yordan, Mets, German | The baseball bats fanatic
Listened to the game through the 4th, lost the game while we were driving.
I saw where Hinch was taking the blame for putting Valdez in……look, if you have a guy in your bullpen you can’t trust, WHY ON EARTH is he taking up a spot??? Luhnow has GOT to get a lefty Hinch can have faith in. George’S injury couldn’t come at a worse time. No Altuve, no Diaz and now no Springer. You can’t take your foot off the rest of the AL West neck! Anybody taking bets if we see Alveraz this week?
LikeLike
Maybe shoulda had Kemp at 2nd, Yuli at 1st and White in the Bullpen. Two tough pop ups in the sun, but catch them and you win.
LikeLiked by 1 person
Good road trip. Had a chance to take 3 of 3 from the Sox but overall pleased. Hope there are no lingering issues with Springer as we sure need him to be there for us. Really interested if we’re going to try to do a long term deal with him this year. He does have one more year of arbitration left (2020). I just think we should make every effort to retain him. Do we have any LH relief specialists that could take Framber’s place? If the pop fly doesn’t get dropped and Bett’s is not on 1st does Chavis score from 1st on the double? Also 0 for 5 with RISP. A disappointment to say the least. Another tester coming up in the homestand with the Red Sox over the weekend and the Cubs for 3 more. Looking forward to some good baseball. Should beat up on the White Sox.
LikeLike
Not sure how Perez is doing as a starter, but I would trust him to take Framber Valdez’s spot right now. Heck…..I’d rather see Tony Sipp coming out of the bullpen, rather than Valdez!! Some things need to be addressed SOON!
LikeLike
Keeping one eye on the newest Joe Pickett novel and one eye on the weather in south central OK. Things are fixin’ to get Western in both of those places. Storm shelter is ready and phones are charged up.
LikeLike
Saw that OP……We will pray you through it. Stay safe.
LikeLike
When y’all go in storm shelter, where do animals go?
LikeLike
The dogs have their houses.
The chickens have their house.
The lambs and goats have a covered area in their pen, as do the show calves.
Ranger has a pen outside and in the shop. He’ll be in the shop.
Trouble is, if a tornado hits, the shelter is the only safe place and it will have a bunch of us in it. Seven of us in an in-ground concrete room the size of a walk-in closet.
This would be the second time this year for us to be in it and the third time since we’ve had it. Before we had the shelter, we would hop in our car and drive the opposite direction of the storm and then circle out of it’s way.
I will say this: cell phone internet with access to radar is a wonderful thing. And if a tornado watch is in our vicinity our cell phones go off like sirens.
LikeLiked by 1 person
Hang in there old pro – prayers are up for all those in harms way
LikeLiked by 1 person
Stay Safe OP!
LikeLike
Wow, that was a lot of information, OP, and interesting, and concerning. Thank you.
LikeLike
I can’t really think about hanging that loss on Framber. Too many other things happened during that game. He got five outs without walking anyone and they had one well hit ball off him. That was the big run, but we could have avoided at least two, going back to the one we gave up in the first inning.
I think we need a quality outing from Peacock tonight. After a such a great stretch, I could see the bats a bit hungover.
LikeLike
I agree with you. Framber’s run was the result of good hitting. And Betts scored because there was two outs and he was running on the pitch. The guy he replaced, as the result of the misplayed popup, would have scored anyway, as he was the leadoff guy who would have been running on the same pitch.
You could have blamed the other three runs on a bunch of others, but I consider this loss is the result of not having Springer, Altuve, Gurriel, White and Diaz not in their normal positions and it caught up with the team in a tight game against a tough team on the road at the end of a long road trip.
LikeLiked by 1 person
Luke Gregerson has been released by the Cards. I guess now he’ll badmouth them.
LikeLiked by 1 person
Against the Rangers, when we swept them, our offense averaged over 10 hits per game. Against the Tigers, when we swept them, our offense averaged over 1o hits per game. Against the Red Sox, from whom we took 2 0f 3, we averaged a little over 7 hits per game [and in the one game we lost, we only got 4 hits].
What excites me is that, even when averaging fewer that 10 hits per game against the Bosox, we still managed to win 2 out of 3 games. Add to that the fact that we were without both Altuve and Diaz – and had maybe half a George Springer – when facing the Bosox, and that series win is even more impressive.
LikeLike
How about adding in a 23 yo rookie pitcher making his second start and it’s against the WS Champs. Then your #3 pitches against their ace in game 3 and gets a draw. I think we did very well indeed.
LikeLike
Yes!
LikeLike
Correa hits an absolute bullet of a sac fly in the 1st inning.
Marisnick waves that stick and puts up a Dinger instead of Springer.
LikeLike
And our national nightmare is over as Tyler White pulls ahead of the pitching staff in home runs hit.
LikeLike
Great outing by Peacock. He’s done right?
Nephew was way, way overdue. I’m afraid to get overly enthusiastic yet.
LikeLike
Devenski had not pitched in 8 days. Hope he’s worked out his issues.
LikeLike
Devo seemed to have pretty good movement on his slider and kept them off balanced. A good outing. Hope we see more of it. And the tuna morphs into the shark again.
LikeLike
Great pitching and just enough hitting – nice win for the good guys.
LikeLike
Excellent win. Stay safe everyone in that rough weather zone!
LikeLike
Brad had a good game again tonight! Nine strikeouts, but they sure made him work for those strikeouts! Very good to see homeruns by two guys who haven’t exactly set the world on fire with their bats. Good game fellas!
OP…..good grief I saw the weather radar😨! Stay safe friend🙏
LikeLike
Kyle Tucker is ripping the ball now after a terrible April. He is up to .252 BA / .331 OBP / .919 which considering he was batting .100 not that long ago is a big improvement. He’s scored 25 runs hit 12 HRs and knocked in 28 in 39 games. Good to see.
LikeLike
That’s great, but can he do this at the MLB level? Ah! Now that is the question.
LikeLike
My guess is that he will be able to. What seems to get lost in the Tucker story is the fact that he is only 22 years old and was drafted out of HS.
George Springer had 3 years of college, almost 3 years in the minors and three years in the majors before he became an MLB star at age 27 and a superstar at age 29.
Tucker is very, very young.
LikeLike
I’m optimistic too. Maybe we were expecting too much too soon based on his MILB stats. Look how many prospects have been touted to be the next superstars only to fall short of expectations. On the other hand, how many low draftees became good and great ball players. You just never know. Kind of like the stock market, or the tables in Lost Wages.
LikeLike
Kyle Tucker, April 2019: 22 games, .173/.221/.407, 21K:5BB
Kyle Tucker, May 2019: 17 games, .355/.459/.823, 18K:11BB
LikeLike
-The team with the best record in MLB has turned the fewest DPs in MLB, 22.
– The Astros now have the second lowest team ERA in MLB, behind the Rays.
Their bullpen has the lowest ERA in MLB.
-I guess you’re a pretty good hitting team if you are second in MLB in HRs, first in BA and have the second fewest strikeouts in MLB.
LikeLike
Just dreamily wondering if there would ever be a lineup like this for the Astros:
Springer CF
Altuve 2B
Bregman 3B
Alvarez LF
Correa SS
Tucker LF
Toro 1B
Beer DH
Stubbs C
Every player having played their entire minor league career in the Astros system.
LikeLike
That would be beyond crazy – old pro – only happens when a team is ditching it and in this case that would not be happening…
LikeLike
Like it Beer has been great in his few games at CC. i really like Toro also
LikeLike